When is it worth refinancing a mortgage?
Refinancing is worth it only if what you save over time exceeds what you pay to do it. Here is how to judge that with numbers, plus an example calculated with the same engine as the calculator.
The basic rule: cumulative savings after costs
Compare what you would pay to the end with your current loan against what you would pay with the new offer, then subtract the one-time refinancing costs. If the result is positive, refinancing saves money. The month from which cumulative savings stay positive is the break-even point.
A lower rate is not enough on its own. What happens after the fixed-rate period matters too, that is, the offer’s margin versus your current margin, and how long the remaining term is over which the difference applies.
The three things that decide it
- How much the rate drops during the fixed period. The rate difference applies to the remaining balance, so it matters more on larger balances.
- The margin after the fixed period. A lower margin over IRCC (or ROBOR) saves money for the rest of the loan; the same margin means all the gain comes from the fixed period.
- The one-time costs. Notary and OCPI fees, file analysis, valuation, origination fee. They are paid upfront, so a lower payment has to win them back before you really save.
Worked example
A loan of 250,000 RON with 20 years left, now at 8.07% (IRCC 5.57% plus a 2.50% margin). One-time refinancing costs: 1,500 RON.
Offer A (5.49% fixed for 5 years, then IRCC + 2.00%) lowers the monthly payment by about 383.70 RON and saves 47,239.07 RON after costs, breaking even in month 4. Offer B (4.89% fixed for 3 years, then the same margin as now) saves 27,764.55 RON, mainly from the fixed period.
The figures are indicative, with IRCC constant. If IRCC rises after the fixed period the result changes, which is why the calculator has IRCC scenarios.
The retention threshold: what to do with your current bank
The retention threshold is the fixed rate at which staying with your current bank costs the same as the new offer. If your bank offers a rate below the threshold you can stay without refinancing and without the one-time costs. If its proposal is above the threshold, the new offer is still better. The calculator shows it for each offer.
When it usually is not worth it
- The remaining balance is small and the remaining term is short: the monthly saving never covers the costs.
- The rate difference is tiny and the offer’s margin does not make up for it.
- One-time costs are large compared with the monthly saving, so the break-even point is far away.
- You plan to sell or repay the loan before the break-even point anyway.
How to check your own case
Enter the balance, the remaining term, the monthly payment from your bank app and up to 6 offers with their costs in the calculator. You get the total savings, the break-even point and the retention threshold. For costs see the guide to refinancing costs.
Frequently asked questions
How long does it take to recover the refinancing costs?
It depends on the monthly saving. Divide the one-time costs by the difference in the monthly payment: in the example above, the 1,500 RON costs are recovered within a short time on offer A. The exact figure over the whole loan is the break-even point in the calculator.
Can I refinance with the same bank?
Yes, many customers negotiate with their current bank holding another bank’s offer. The retention threshold shows how low a rate is worth staying for. Note that costs (notary, OCPI) can still arise if the mortgage is replaced.
Is refinancing worth it with a variable rate?
It can be, if an offer with a rate fixed for several years steadies your payment or if the new margin is lower. Check which index your loan uses (IRCC or ROBOR) and test the IRCC scenarios in the calculator.
Sources
Work out the refinancing for your own case
Enter your current loan and up to 6 offers and see the total savings, the break-even point and the retention threshold. Free, no account, your data stays in your browser.